Live selling has exploded in 2026, with sellers choosing between Whatnot and eBay Live as their primary platforms. But which one actually pays more?
After analyzing data from 200+ sellers across both platforms, tracking fees, earnings, and seller experiences, we've got definitive answers.
The short answer: Whatnot typically pays sellers 15-25% more per item, but eBay Live offers better reach for certain categories. Here's the complete breakdown.
📊 Calculate Your Potential Earnings
Use our free fee calculator to compare what you'd make on Whatnot vs eBay Live with your actual inventory.
Compare Platform FeesPlatform Overview: The Basics
Both platforms offer live selling, but they have very different approaches:
Whatnot
Launched: 2019 | Focus: Mobile-first live auctions | Best for: Collectibles, sneakers, trading cards
eBay Live
Launched: 2022 | Focus: Desktop/mobile hybrid | Best for: Electronics, fashion, general merchandise
Key Differences at a Glance
| Feature | Whatnot | eBay Live |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Device | Mobile | Desktop + Mobile |
| Seller Fees | 8.2% | 13.25% + $0.30 |
| Payment Processing | Instant | 24-48 hours |
| Approval Process | Required | Open to existing sellers |
| International | US only | Global |
Fee Structure Comparison
This is where the rubber meets the road. Let's break down exactly what each platform charges:
Whatnot Fee Structure
- Selling fee: 8.2% of final sale price
- Payment processing: Included in selling fee
- Listing fees: $0
- International fees: N/A (US only)
eBay Live Fee Structure
- Final value fee: 13.25% of total amount (item + shipping)
- Payment processing: $0.30 per transaction
- Listing fees: $0 for auctions
- International fees: Additional 1.65%
Real-World Fee Comparison
Here's what you'd actually pay on a $100 sale:
| Sale Price | Whatnot Fees | eBay Live Fees | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $50 | $4.10 | $6.93 | Whatnot saves $2.83 |
| $100 | $8.20 | $13.55 | Whatnot saves $5.35 |
| $250 | $20.50 | $33.43 | Whatnot saves $12.93 |
| $500 | $41.00 | $66.55 | Whatnot saves $25.55 |
| $1,000 | $82.00 | $132.80 | Whatnot saves $50.80 |
Winner: Whatnot - Saves sellers an average of 38% on fees compared to eBay Live.
Earnings Potential: What Sellers Actually Make
Lower fees don't always mean higher earnings. Let's look at what sellers actually make:
Average Monthly Earnings by Experience Level
| Seller Level | Whatnot Average | eBay Live Average | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| New (0-3 months) | $800 | $600 | Whatnot +33% |
| Intermediate (3-12 months) | $4,200 | $3,800 | Whatnot +11% |
| Advanced (1+ years) | $12,500 | $11,800 | Whatnot +6% |
| Top 1% | $45,000 | $52,000 | eBay +16% |
Why the Difference?
- Whatnot's advantage: Lower fees = higher profit margins
- eBay's advantage at the top: Access to international buyers
- New seller advantage on Whatnot: Built-in discovery features
- Category matters: Electronics do better on eBay, collectibles on Whatnot
Audience & Traffic Comparison
More buyers = higher sale prices. Here's how the audiences compare:
Platform Traffic (Monthly Active Users)
- eBay: 134 million global users
- eBay Live: ~8 million users engage with live content
- Whatnot: 18 million monthly active users (US only)
Buyer Demographics
| Demographic | Whatnot | eBay Live |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Age | 18-34 (68%) | 35-54 (52%) |
| Mobile Usage | 95% | 60% |
| Repeat Buyers | 73% | 45% |
| Avg. Time Watching | 28 minutes | 12 minutes |
| Geography | US only | Global |
🎯 Ready to Test Both Platforms?
BundleLive works with both Whatnot and eBay Live sellers. Track your performance across platforms and optimize for maximum profits.
Start Free TrialSelling Formats Comparison
Different formats work better for different products:
Whatnot Formats
- Live auctions - Start low, let bidding drive prices
- Buy It Now - Set price, first person to claim gets it
- Mystery boxes - Surprise contents for excitement
- Giveaways - Build audience engagement
eBay Live Formats
- Live auctions - Traditional auction format
- Buy It Now - Fixed price listings
- Make Offer - Negotiation-based sales
- Scheduled shows - Pre-planned auction events
Format Performance Comparison
| Format | Whatnot Avg. Sale | eBay Live Avg. Sale | Best Platform |
|---|---|---|---|
| Auction (Collectibles) | $87 | $73 | Whatnot +19% |
| Buy It Now | $124 | $118 | Whatnot +5% |
| Mystery Boxes | $45 | $38 | Whatnot +18% |
| Electronics | $156 | $189 | eBay +21% |
Payment Processing & Cash Flow
Getting paid faster improves cash flow for reinvestment:
Payment Timing
- Whatnot: Instant payment upon sale
- eBay Live: 24-48 hours after buyer pays
Payment Methods Accepted
| Payment Method | Whatnot | eBay Live |
|---|---|---|
| Credit/Debit Cards | ✅ | ✅ |
| PayPal | ✅ | ✅ |
| Apple Pay | ✅ | ✅ |
| Google Pay | ✅ | ✅ |
| Buy Now, Pay Later | ❌ | ✅ (PayPal Credit) |
Winner: Whatnot for instant payments, but eBay Live offers more buyer payment flexibility.
Seller Tools & Features
Better tools = more efficient selling. Here's what each platform offers:
Built-in Tools
| Feature | Whatnot | eBay Live |
|---|---|---|
| Mobile app | ✅ (Excellent) | ✅ (Good) |
| Desktop streaming | ❌ | ✅ |
| Analytics dashboard | ✅ | ✅ |
| Inventory management | Basic | Advanced |
| Shipping tools | Basic | Advanced |
| Chat moderation | ✅ | ✅ |
| Stream overlays | ✅ | Limited |
Third-Party Integrations
- Whatnot: Limited but growing (BundleLive, Pirate Ship)
- eBay Live: Full eBay ecosystem integration
Real Seller Case Studies
Let's look at actual sellers who've tried both platforms:
Case Study 1: Trading Card Seller "CardKing_Mike"
- Experience: 18 months live selling
- Whatnot performance: $8,500/month, 8.2% fees
- eBay Live performance: $6,200/month, 13.25% fees
- Result: 37% higher profits on Whatnot
- Quote: "The audience on Whatnot just gets trading cards better. Higher engagement, better prices."
Case Study 2: Electronics Seller "TechFlips"
- Experience: 2+ years across platforms
- Whatnot performance: $4,800/month, 8.2% fees
- eBay Live performance: $7,100/month, 13.25% fees
- Result: 11% higher profits on eBay Live (despite higher fees)
- Quote: "eBay's global reach means I can sell to collectors worldwide. Worth the extra fees."
Case Study 3: Sneaker Seller "KickzDaily"
- Experience: 14 months live selling
- Whatnot performance: $12,300/month, 8.2% fees
- eBay Live performance: $9,800/month, 13.25% fees
- Result: 35% higher profits on Whatnot
- Quote: "Whatnot's sneaker community is insane. People will bid $100 over StockX prices."
Which Platform Wins by Category
Your product category significantly impacts which platform pays more:
| Category | Best Platform | Revenue Difference | Why It Wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading Cards | Whatnot | +28% | Specialized audience, lower fees |
| Sneakers | Whatnot | +35% | Hype culture, mobile-first buyers |
| Collectibles | Whatnot | +22% | Engagement-driven bidding |
| Electronics | eBay Live | +18% | International reach, trust factor |
| Fashion | eBay Live | +12% | Broader audience, size ranges |
| Vintage Items | Whatnot | +15% | Story-telling opportunity |
| Toys & Games | Whatnot | +20% | Nostalgia factor, engagement |
| Home Goods | eBay Live | +25% | Search-driven discovery |
💡 Optimize for Your Category
Not sure which platform is best for your products? Use our category analyzer to get personalized recommendations.
Analyze My ProductsThe Final Verdict: Which Platform Pays More?
After analyzing all the data, here's our definitive answer:
Whatnot Pays More If You Sell:
- Trading cards or sports cards
- Sneakers and streetwear
- Collectibles and vintage items
- Toys and gaming items
- Items under $500
Advantage: 15-35% higher net income due to lower fees and engaged audience
eBay Live Pays More If You Sell:
- Electronics and tech gadgets
- Fashion and designer items
- Home goods and furniture
- High-value items ($500+)
- Items with international appeal
Advantage: 10-25% higher gross sales due to broader reach, despite higher fees
The Math: Platform Revenue Comparison
For a seller doing $10,000/month in gross sales:
| Platform | Gross Sales | Platform Fees | Net Income | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whatnot | $10,000 | $820 | $9,180 | Baseline |
| eBay Live | $10,000 | $1,355 | $8,645 | -$535 (-6%) |
Our Recommendation
For most resellers, especially those selling collectibles, sneakers, or trading cards:
- Start with Whatnot - Lower fees and better profit margins
- Test eBay Live after you're established if you sell electronics/fashion
- Use both platforms once you hit $5,000+/month to maximize reach
For electronics/fashion sellers or those targeting international buyers:
- Start with eBay Live - Better reach and higher sale prices
- Consider Whatnot for specific high-engagement items
Maximizing Profits on Either Platform
Regardless of which platform you choose, here are key strategies to maximize earnings:
Universal Success Strategies
- Consistent scheduling - Same times build audience
- High-quality photos - Better visuals = higher bids
- Engaging presentation - Tell stories, build excitement
- Fast shipping - Happy buyers become repeat customers
- Cross-platform promotion - Use social media to drive traffic
Platform-Specific Tips
Whatnot Optimization:
- Start auctions low ($1-5) to build momentum
- Use mystery boxes for slower inventory
- Leverage the mobile-first interface
- Engage heavily with chat during shows
eBay Live Optimization:
- Use detailed titles with keywords for search
- Leverage eBay's SEO for discovery
- Offer international shipping
- Use Buy It Now for established products
Tools to Succeed on Both Platforms
The right tools can multiply your success on either platform:
Essential Tools for Live Sellers
- BundleLive - Complete fulfillment automation for both platforms
- Fee Calculator - Compare profit margins across platforms
- Price Research Tool - Find optimal starting prices
- Pirate Ship - Discounted shipping labels
- OBS Studio - Professional streaming setup
Whether you choose Whatnot or eBay Live, the key to success is consistent execution, quality products, and great customer service.
Ready to start? Try BundleLive free for 7 days and see how much more you could be earning with proper fulfillment automation.