1859-S Indian Head Penny XF40

US Mint · Indian Head Penny

$4 - $368
Estimated resale value · as of February 2026
➡️ Stable

🏆 Best Platform: eBay

Based on category, fees, and buyer demand for coins.

💰 Fee Comparison - What You'd Net

PlatformFeeYou Net (at $186)
eBay ⭐13.13% + $0.30$161.54
StockX9.5%$168.60
Poshmark20%$149.04
Mercari10%$167.67
GOAT9.5% + $5$163.60
Whatnot8.2%$171.02

📋 Product Details

mint
S
year
1859
grade
XF40

1859-S Indian Head Penny graded XF40.

🔗 Related Products

1859-P Indian Head Penny MS63

$7 - $873

US Mint · eBay

1896-CC Indian Head Penny MS60

$8 - $688

US Mint · PCGS

1897-D Indian Head Penny F12

$6 - $538

US Mint · eBay

1905-O Indian Head Penny MS66

$7 - $688

US Mint · Heritage Auctions

1891-D Indian Head Penny AU55

$5 - $552

US Mint · PCGS

Track all your resale profits → BundleLive free trial ⚡

Free 7-day trial. No credit card required.