1909 Indian Head Penny S

How much does 1909 Indian Head Penny S sell for? Here's the latest sold price data.
Last updated: February 2026 · Based on 107 recent sales
Average Sold Price
$500
across all platforms
Price Range
$330 – $720
low to high
Trending
Rising
vs. last 30 days

💰 Best Platform to Sell This

After fees, here's what you'd actually take home selling at the average price of $500:

Best Take-Home
Whatnot
8.9% seller fee
$456
your take-home
Mercari
10% selling fee
$450
your take-home
eBay
13.13% final value fee
$434
your take-home
Poshmark
20% commission
$400
your take-home

📈 Price History

📊

Price history chart — coming soon with live eBay data integration

Average: $500 · Trending upward

🏷️ Recent Sold Listings

Date Price Condition Platform
Feb 8, 2026 $567 MS-65 eBay
Jan 21, 2026 $576 Fine eBay
Jan 26, 2026 $506 VF-30 eBay
Jan 24, 2026 $452 VF-30 Whatnot
Feb 8, 2026 $371 MS-65 eBay
Jan 30, 2026 $706 VF-30 eBay
Jan 29, 2026 $476 VF-30 eBay
Jan 21, 2026 $535 VF-30 Whatnot
Jan 16, 2026 $330 AU-58 Mercari
Jan 16, 2026 $485 XF-45 eBay

🔗 Similar Items

Want instant pricing for ANY item?

SnapList uses AI to identify and price items from a photo. Just point, snap, and list.